Part 1 of a series on Dąbrowski, overexcitability, and giftedness
If you’ve read about giftedness, you’ve probably come across the term overexcitability. The five forms described by Polish psychiatrist Kazimierz Dąbrowski are often presented as characteristics of gifted individuals. Sometimes, they’re even used to help identify giftedness. But that was never their original purpose.
In his 2026 article Overexcitability Reconsidered: Domestication of a Developmental Theory, Chris Wells traces how overexcitability moved from Dąbrowski’s clinical work into gifted education. Over time, a concept originally embedded in a theory of personality development came to be treated as a defining characteristic of giftedness. Wells’ historical analysis raises a question I consider particularly important in my work with gifted adults: What did Dąbrowski actually mean by overexcitability, and how did it fit into his broader theory of personality development?
What is overexcitability in Dabrowski’s theory?
Kazimierz Dąbrowski described overexcitability as heightened psychological responsiveness to internal and external stimuli. He identified five forms of overexcitability, which he considered potential components of developmental potential within his Theory of Positive Disintegration. Overexcitability was not developed as a tool for identifying giftedness. Its original significance lies in Dąbrowski’s attempt to understand how personality develops through psychological conflict and, under certain conditions, positive disintegration.
The clinical origins of overexcitability
Kazimierz Dąbrowski (1902–1980) was a Polish psychiatrist and psychologist whose work challenged conventional assumptions about mental health and personality development. In his clinical practice, he encountered people experiencing intense emotions, inner conflicts, and psychological distress. Rather than automatically interpreting these experiences as symptoms of mental illness, he asked whether some forms of psychological disturbance might also be associated with developmental processes.
His thinking reminds me of the work of Dutch psychiatrist and researcher Jim van Os, who advocates a recovery-oriented approach to mental health. Van Os emphasizes understanding psychological distress in the context of a person’s life rather than automatically treating it as evidence of a psychiatric disorder or allowing a diagnosis to define someone’s identity. In his 2026 book Wat psychisch lijden is, en waarom je niet ziek bent bij mentale moeilijkheden, Van Os explores this perspective in contemporary mental health care.
Dąbrowski approached these questions from his own theoretical perspective. He drew on earlier psychiatric concepts of nervousness and heightened sensitivity, gradually developing the concept of overexcitability as part of his research into developmental potential (Wells & Falk, 2021). He wanted to understand how heightened psychological responsiveness might influence a person’s development. That question became part of a much larger theory.
The five forms of overexcitability
Dąbrowski understood overexcitability as a feature of an individual’s psychological constitution. He distinguished five forms:
- Psychomotor overexcitability
- Sensual overexcitability
- Imaginational overexcitability
- Intellectual overexcitability
- Emotional overexcitability
These were never intended to function as a simple checklist of personality traits. Within his theory, Dąbrowski was interested in how different forms of overexcitability interacted and how their configuration might contribute to developmental potential. He assigned particular developmental significance to emotional, imaginational, and intellectual overexcitability. In his view, psychomotor and sensual overexcitability could contribute energy or intensity but were not sufficient on their own for more advanced personality development. These were theoretical propositions, not established diagnostic criteria.
No particular form of overexcitability has been validated as a reliable predictor of personality development or as a means of identifying giftedness.

Photo: Robin Godefridi / Pexels
Overexcitability and developmental potential
To understand the original significance of overexcitability, we need to examine its place within Dąbrowski’s concept of developmental potential. Developmental potential refers to the psychological characteristics and capacities that, according to his theory, influence a person’s possibilities for development. In Psychoneurosis Is Not an Illness (1972), Dąbrowski discussed overexcitabilities alongside special abilities, talents, and autonomous developmental factors. Their presence did not guarantee that personality development would occur.
Dąbrowski believed that different configurations of developmental potential could lead to different developmental possibilities. Some might contribute to constructive development, while others could be associated with difficulties or less favorable developmental outcomes. This matters because intensity is often described today as though it were inherently valuable. Within Dąbrowski’s theory, however, intense experiences do not automatically indicate psychological maturity or personal growth. The question is how particular psychological characteristics might contribute to development within the broader organization of the personality. Even within his own theoretical framework, identifying overexcitability would not be sufficient to establish someone’s developmental potential or level of personality development.
What did Dąbrowski mean by positive disintegration?
Dąbrowski’s Theory of Positive Disintegration proposes that personality development can involve a breakdown of an individual’s existing psychological organization. He used the term disintegration to describe processes in which previously established patterns, beliefs, and values may lose their coherence. Someone may begin questioning convictions that once seemed unquestionable. Ways of understanding oneself that previously felt consistent may become difficult to reconcile. Dąbrowski believed that certain inner conflicts could contribute to the development of a more complex personality structure.
But he made an important distinction: disintegration is not necessarily positive. Psychological disturbance may also lead to stagnation or deterioration in functioning. Within his theory, disintegration becomes positive when it contributes to the development of a new personality organization characterized by greater autonomy and a consciously developed hierarchy of values.
Unilevel and multilevel disintegration
Dąbrowski distinguished between unilevel and multilevel disintegration. In unilevel disintegration, according to his theory, a clear internal hierarchy among competing possibilities and values has not yet emerged. In multilevel disintegration, individuals begin to develop an internal hierarchy through which they evaluate their own qualities and motives. An emerging personality ideal provides a reference point for deciding which qualities they wish to cultivate and which they consciously want to change. This is central to Dąbrowski’s understanding of development. He did not view personality development simply as becoming more self-aware or learning to regulate intense emotions. His theory describes a process in which individuals increasingly evaluate themselves according to an internally developed ideal. The process involves psychological forces that Dąbrowski called dynamisms. These dynamisms occupy an important place in his account of multilevel development.
The third factor and autonomous development
One of the central concepts in Dąbrowski’s theory is the third factor. Dąbrowski used this term to describe an emerging capacity for autonomous self-evaluation and self-determination. Within his theory, individuals increasingly take responsibility for shaping their own development. They begin to evaluate which qualities and values they wish to strengthen, guided by an emerging personality ideal. The third factor is more specific than ordinary self-reflection or making independent decisions. It belongs to the developmental processes Dąbrowski associated with more advanced, multilevel personality development. This distinction becomes important when overexcitability is discussed in isolation.
Why overexcitability cannot be separated from the broader theory
This is where the original meaning of overexcitability matters most to me. When overexcitability is described simply as heightened intensity, attention shifts toward how strongly someone experiences the world. Dąbrowski was interested in a broader question. He wanted to understand how psychological responsiveness might interact with developmental potential, inner conflicts, and the emergence of autonomous developmental processes. Those relationships are essential to his theory. Consider someone who becomes deeply involved in moral questions and experiences strong emotions when confronted with injustice. From Dąbrowski’s theoretical perspective, those experiences might offer a starting point for exploring developmental potential.
But they do not establish that the person has a particular form of overexcitability, is experiencing positive disintegration, or has reached a specific developmental level. Those conclusions would require much more than observing intensity or hearing someone describe an emotional experience. There is also a scientific limitation to consider. The developmental levels and dynamisms proposed in Dąbrowski’s theory have not all been adequately validated through empirical research. For professionals, this distinction matters. We can use a theory to explore experiences without assuming that the theory provides an established explanation for every individual case.
In my book Had ik dit maar eerder geweten over ACT & hoogbegaafdheid, I explore how Dąbrowski’s ideas relate to personal development and the process of making conscious choices.
How overexcitability became associated with giftedness
Dąbrowski himself recognized possible connections among overexcitability, exceptional abilities, creativity, and giftedness. However, he did not develop overexcitability as a method for measuring intelligence. Beginning in the late 1970s, the concept gained a more prominent place in gifted education, particularly through the work of Michael Piechowski (1979). Researchers and educators became interested in whether gifted students experienced particular forms of overexcitability more frequently or more intensely than their peers.
Wells (2026) describes how the concept gradually acquired a different function. Rather than remaining primarily part of a theory of personality development, overexcitability increasingly came to be presented as a characteristic associated with giftedness. This shift raised a new research question: Could overexcitability be used to identify gifted individuals? Answering that question requires evidence that goes beyond the theoretical significance Dąbrowski originally assigned to the concept.
What does current research tell us?
A meta-analysis by Olszewski-Kubilius and colleagues (2026) examined 230 effect sizes from 20 empirical studies investigating the relationship between overexcitabilities and giftedness. The researchers found that the results depended substantially on how giftedness was defined and identified. When giftedness was defined exclusively through measured general intelligence or cognitive ability, they found no statistically significant association with overexcitabilities. These findings do not support using overexcitability questionnaires as stand-alone tools for identifying giftedness.
Using overexcitability scores to conclude that someone is gifted goes beyond what these instruments have been validated to measure.
The distinction is particularly important in professional practice, where an assessment or explanation may influence how someone understands their identity. The meta-analysis did not evaluate Dąbrowski’s entire Theory of Positive Disintegration. It did not investigate the validity of his proposed developmental levels, the role of the third factor, or the broader processes of personality development described in his work. We therefore cannot use its findings either to validate or to reject those aspects of the theory. I will examine the meta-analysis in greater detail in the next article in this series.
What does this mean for professional practice?
Dąbrowski developed his theory to explore how personality development might occur and how psychological tensions and inner conflicts could contribute to that process. For professionals working with gifted adults, the theory may provide a conceptual framework for examining questions about personal development. That possibility comes with an important responsibility. A theoretical interpretation is not the same as an established conclusion about an individual.
A theory may help us understand experiences and explore their meaning in conversation. That does not demonstrate that an intervention based on the theory is effective. Nor does it justify using overexcitability to determine someone’s intelligence, identify giftedness, or assign a developmental level within Dąbrowski’s theory. This is particularly relevant when clients are searching for explanations that may influence how they view themselves. A person may have spent years trying to understand experiences that seemed difficult to explain.
When a professional offers an interpretation, it can become part of that person’s understanding of their identity. That influence deserves careful consideration. As professionals, we need to distinguish between what a theory proposes, what research has established, and what we can reasonably conclude about the individual sitting across from us. For me, this is an essential part of responsible professional practice.
Returning to Dąbrowski’s original questions
Dąbrowski’s work was ultimately concerned with how personality might develop toward greater autonomy and an internally established hierarchy of values. Overexcitability was one possible component of developmental potential within that larger theoretical framework. Its significance lay in how it might relate to other developmental processes. Understanding that original context matters when we consider how the concept is used today.
In the next article, I’ll examine what current research tells us about the relationship between overexcitability and giftedness. The 2026 meta-analysis by Olszewski-Kubilius and colleagues provides an important starting point. A later article will explore what overexcitability questionnaires actually measure and how their use relates to Dąbrowski’s original concepts.
Why this matters to me
What continues to concern me is how easily a theory can take on a life of its own. Over time, an idea may become so familiar that we stop asking what it was originally meant to explain. That matters when people come to us for guidance. The explanations we offer can shape how they understand themselves, sometimes for years to come. As professionals, we owe them explanations we can stand behind.
In the Netherlands, professional qualifications can be evaluated through organizations such as the Kwaliteitsregister Hoogbegaafdheid and the ECHA professional network. These organizations provide information about specialist training and professional backgrounds, although their registration criteria and areas of expertise differ. Professional expertise should be demonstrated through relevant education, experience, and a willingness to examine the scientific foundations of one’s work.
Explore Dąbrowski’s Theory of Positive Disintegration further
Would you like to learn more about Dąbrowski’s Theory of Positive Disintegration and consider what it might mean for your own development? In my Dutch-language book Had ik dit maar eerder geweten over ACT & hoogbegaafdheid, I explore the relationship between Dąbrowski’s theory, personal development, and the choices we make about the lives we want to lead.